Who picked it: ZombieFace
Why did you pick it: It has white chocolate and I like white chocolate
Ratings (out of 7):
Difficulty level and why: It was a pain to crush candy canes. They do spread a lot so give them room. batch size is small
What the family thought: They were good. The peppermint chunks should be smaller next time
What the consultant thought: They really liked them
Overall score: 5
Who picked it: Cool Man
Why did you pick it: It has lemons in it
Ratings (out of 7):
Difficulty level and why: Not bad. The dough is sticky and rolling it in powdered sugar was messy. Pretty straight forward recipe. Cook time was longer than stated. We cooked for 14 minutes.
What the family thought: They we re good. Cool Man thinks anything with lemon is the best. They were a little gooey for the parents but were much better the second day.
What the consultant thought: They were really good
Overall score: 5.4
What was your favorite cookie? The family liked the Easy peanut butter cup cookies and the Key Lime cookies the best
What was your least favorite cookie? Coconut macaroons and Sweet potato cookies were not the favorite of the family
What did we learn from this experience:
Elyk: Any cookie can be good
ZombieFace: Sweet potato is a flavor you either like or don't like. Outliers can have an affect on the score of the cookie. I pick the best cookies. People have different tastes for cookies
Cool Man: Mom does not like lemon sugar cookies and she ruined my chance to have the favorite cookie
Dad: There are more cookies than just chocolate chip that are good. Don't double the recipe because it says it only make 12 servings.
Mom: You should always look at the ingredients before deciding to make it.
Why did you pick it: It sounded intruging, then I looked at the ingredients and started to be concerned
Ratings (out of 7):
Difficulty level and why: Not bad. The corn flake measurement is before it being crushed not after.
What the family thought: It has an interesting texture and is crunchy and soft at the same time. It has a toffee flavor to them.
What the consultant thought: no one signed up. Their loss!
Overall score: 4.3
Who picked it: Dad
Why did you pick it: Willing to try anything once.
Ratings (out of 7):
Difficulty level and why: fairly easy, but did not know how to mash sweet potatoes.
What the family thought: They were ok. Not a favorite. They may be an attempt to make a healthy cookie. There was only a cup of sugar total.
What the consultant thought:
Overall score: 3.4
Which cookie is going to have the best ranking this quarter
Dad: Sparkly chocolate fudge cookies will be the favorite (Mom and ZombieFace cannot vote) because fudge is good and the sparkles will be the pixy dust that make it that much better
Mom: Honey vanilla linser cookie will be the best because they are sugar cookies and these are the only sugar cookie this quarter. Everyone loves sugar cookies
Elyk: From scratch brownie cookies will be the best cookie because it will have quite a bit of chocolate and just seems good.
ZombieFace: I think lemon cake cookies will be the favorite because I liked the the lemon sandwich cookies last quarter
Cool Man: I think Lemon cake mix and ooey goooey lemon cookies are going to be the top cookie this year because they are lemon cookies. I love lemons and I think they will be like gushers. (he picked two because he is the youngest and gets away with everything)
Which cookie will have the worst ranking
Dad: Triple Ginger cream sandwiches have THREE types of ginger in them. I looked at what evil spirits ginger wards away and there are none. It has no super natural power otherwise our house would be safe for a while.
Mom: Peanut butter banana chocolate chip cookies will be the worst because no one in the house likes bananas except me.
Elyk: Lemon Cake cookies are not going to be popular because they seem to be too sour to even be good
ZombieFace: Almond Joy Cookie with shredded coconut will be the least favorite because I don't like almond joys
Cool Man: I think the butterscotch potato chip balls will be the least favorite because I don't know what type of potato chips are being used. I think we should use the sour cream and onion potato chips.
